By Ashley Fuller
Cherokee Tribune Staff Writer
Two roads are back in unincorporated Cherokee after a hearing Thursday in Cherokee County Superior Court.
Judge Jackson Harris ruled in favor of the county government when he ruled that portions of Sixes and Marble Quarry Roads were not completely annexed by the Holly Springs City Council.
The county in June filed a suit against the Holly Springs city government, challenging the city's 1988 annexation of the two roads. In the lawsuit, the county claims the city, at the time of the annexation, did not adopt a resolution or take any action to complete the annexation.
"The acts in 1988 was a failed attempt in a really big way," Angela Davis, attorney for the county, said in her argument. "You can't just violate any statute. There are laws that matter."
In his ruling, Harris acknowledged the city failed to complete the annexation.
Robert Dyer, attorney for Holly Springs, argued that then-sole county commissioner Gene Hobgood had the authority to turn over roads to the city.
"He had the power to do it, he did it and the county has acquiesced," Dyer said. "You can't go back and challenge your own actions that others have relied on."
Mrs. Davis said the decision puts the roads back into the county and nullifies the annexations of a church at the corner of Marble Quarry and Sixes Roads and a group of annexations last year that includes about 13.5 acres on Sixes Road near Marble Quarry Road. She said the county would have to study whether any other properties are affected by the ruling.
Holly Springs Mayor Tim Downing said the city is considering what steps to take next.
"We are respectful of the judge's opinion," he said. "Right now, we are evaluating our options."
Dyer said an appeal is likely. He said it is up to the city to seek damages for the cost of resurfacing Marble Quarry Road in 2005, a decision that would be determined by a jury.
County Commission Chairman Buzz Ahrens called the decision a victory for the county.
"Obviously, we are pleased with the decision," he said. "The original intent was certainly justified."
The Georgia Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in a separate hearing regarding a lawsuit filed by the county against the city over annexations last year in the Hickory Flat community. That case is scheduled for May 20.
The suit filed last October by the county government challenged a group of annexations up to Hickory and Morgan Roads the city made dating back to the late 1990s. One of the annexations was the property on which the Harmony on the Lake neighborhood was built.
afuller@cherokeetribune.com
|